On April 13, 2026, two small houses at 914 and 916 Dayton Street sold on the same day for $190,000 and $184,000. Both were built in 1906, and the Butler County Auditor lists each one at 826 square feet. That works out to roughly $223 to $230 a square foot, the highest of any priced house sale in the Dayton Lane Historic District over the past year. A month later and a block east, 933 Dayton Street sold for $235,000. It was built in 1893 and has 2,500 square feet, four bedrooms and two full baths, so it cost about $94 a square foot.
The rest of the year's sales follow the same pattern. In Dayton Lane, extra square footage adds little to the price, and what a house sells for depends far more on the individual house than on its size.
The figures below cover the City of Hamilton's map of the Dayton-Campbell district. It includes Dayton Street from 610 to 1045, Campbell Avenue from 719 to 1025, and the short cross-street blocks of Seventh through Tenth Streets. The National Register calls the same area the Dayton-Campbell Historic District. The sale prices come from the Butler County Auditor's Property Sales Last 365 Days report, dated November 2, 2026. The square footage for each house comes from its Auditor parcel record.
Bigger houses, cheaper square feet
These are the priced sales of single-family houses in the district from November 2025 through October 2026, excluding the purchases by investment companies covered in the next section. Price per square foot is the sale price divided by the Auditor's recorded living area.
Address | Built | Living area | Sale date | Price | Per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
914 Dayton St | 1906 | 826 | Apr. 13, 2026 | $190,000 | about $230 |
916 Dayton St | 1906 | 826 | Apr. 13, 2026 | $184,000 | about $223 |
21 N Seventh St | 1900 | 1,934 | Nov. 24, 2025 | $284,466 | about $147 |
924 Campbell Ave | 1884 | 1,802 | Mar. 26, 2026 | $264,000 | about $147 |
1022 Campbell Ave | 1899 | 1,524 | June 22, 2026 | $202,000 | about $133 |
1012 Dayton St | 1900 | 1,321 | July 23, 2026 | $165,000 | about $125 |
1017 Dayton St | 1909 | 2,232 | June 25, 2026 | $255,000 | about $114 |
933 Dayton St | 1893 | 2,500 | May 22, 2026 | $235,000 | about $94 |
820 Dayton St | 1905 | 2,066 | June 3, 2026 | $185,500 | about $90 |
The total prices fall in a fairly tight range, from $165,000 to about $285,000. The price per square foot varies by more than two to one. The houses at the bottom of the table are the large ones. Both 820 Dayton and 933 Dayton have more than 2,000 square feet and four bedrooms, and both sold for less per square foot than any other house on the list. The total prices show that the market is not adding much for a fourth bedroom or a second staircase. On these blocks, a modest house can sell for about what a large one does.
Two doors apart on Campbell Avenue
The sales left out of the table show the same pattern from the other side. On August 25, 2026, 918 Campbell Avenue sold to Bougie Flips LLC for $65,000. It was built in 1889 and has 1,994 square feet, which puts the price at about $33 a square foot. This was a city sale, so has little no weight in comparing sales value for future homes. Five months earlier, 924 Campbell sold for $264,000. It is on the same block, five years older, and about 200 square feet smaller. Both are two-story frame houses from the 1880s on the same street, and one sold for roughly four times as much as the other.
Dayton Street had a similar pair. In March 2026, 826 Dayton changed hands twice in fifteen days. Gedrose Group LLC bought it for $60,000 on March 9 and sold it to Rooted Collective LLC for $100,000 on March 24. It was built in 1915 and has 1,394 square feet, so the second price comes to about $72 a square foot. Gedrose Group LLC also sold the two 1906 houses at 914 and 916 Dayton in April for about $230 and $223 a square foot. In one spring, the same company bought on the low end of this market and sold on the high end. Next door, 820 Dayton sold in June for $185,500.
On August 24, 2026, Revive House LLC bought 850 Campbell Avenue for $126,000. It was built in 1900 and has 1,536 square feet. Over the year, purchases by investment companies in the district ranged from $60,000 to $126,000, while the other priced house sales ranged from $165,000 to about $285,000.
What restoration has looked like on these blocks
Two 1880s houses on one block of Campbell Avenue sold at $33 and $147 a square foot. The association's own house histories show what restoration on Dayton Street has involved, and how long it can take. The Dayton Lane Historic Area Association's account of the Rentschler House at 643 Dayton Street says the house sat vacant for 12 years before it was bought in 2014 and then restored by its current owners. Its slate roof dates to 1901. According to the association, 937 Dayton Street is a 12-room Queen Anne with 3,300 square feet that was built in 1894. It was converted back to a single-family home in 2007, and it still has four original fireplaces, pocket doors and woodwork. At 610 Dayton Street, a half-timbered Queen Anne from 1883, the restoration kept seven Victorian mantels, patterned wood floors and leaded glass. It also turned the carriage house into usable space that still includes the old horse stalls.
Set against the regional median
The comparison buyers usually make is with the wider Cincinnati market. In the five counties covered by the Cincinnati REALTOR Alliance's October 2026 report, the median sold price for the month was $309,000, up 0.6% from October 2025. Active inventory was up 12.6% over the same period, and the median home sold in 14 days. All of the finished-house sales in the table closed below that median. Butler County is one of the five counties in the report. A buyer with a budget near the regional median could afford a four-bedroom house on Dayton Street with money left for work on it.
The Auditor's own figures are also moving toward these sale prices. Butler County's last reappraisal was in 2026, and the Auditor describes the new values as tentative. For tax year 2026, the total value of 924 Campbell rose from $66,910 to $149,460. The value of 1012 Dayton rose from $37,640 to $115,120, and the value of 21 N Seventh rose from $84,960 to $172,450. A buyer estimating the cost of owning one of these houses should look up its 2026 figure on the Auditor's site. These are general figures, not legal, tax or financial advice, so check your own numbers with a qualified professional.
A few questions buyers ask
Is every house on Dayton Street inside the district? No. The city's map includes Dayton Street from 610 to 1045 and Campbell Avenue from 719 to 1025. It also lists some local-only parcels on North Seventh Street that are not on the National Register. Because the map dates from 2011, check a specific parcel against the city's current zoning map.
Can I see the restored houses before buying here? The association holds its May Promenade, a walking tour of houses on Dayton Street and Campbell Avenue, every other year. The most recent one was on May 31, 2026. Our Dayton Lane neighborhood page has more on the district's architecture.
Does the pattern hold for sellers? The sales above suggest that a seller with a large house is better served by showing its finished rooms and original features than by leading with square footage. Our seller resources and home valuation page start from that point.
Victoria Torgersen can review the recorded sales and the Auditor records for the specific house you are considering.